Meta has warned Canadian lawmakers that it may consider pulling encrypted services from the country if the federal government passes its proposed lawful access legislation without further amendments. Speaking before a Senate committee reviewing Bill C-22, company representatives this week argued that the draft law would force technology companies to compromise digital security in order to comply with police warrants.Bill C-22, which passed the House of Commons in June, requires electronic service providers to adapt their systems so that they can hand over user data to investigators upon request. Critics say the mandate directly threatens end-to-end encryption, which is the security standard used by platforms like WhatsApp, Facebook, and Instagram to ensure messages can only be read by the sender and recipient.“Ultimately, the Canadian government would be enforcing and imposing a law that it is not technically feasible to comply with and still offer secure, end-to-end encrypted services to Canadians,” Robyn Greene, Meta’s director of privacy and public policy, testified before senators, according to a report in CBC.When pressed on whether the company would withdraw products from the Canadian market if the bill becomes law, Rachel Curran, Meta’s head of public policy for Canada, said the company would have to “review all of our options.” Curran previously told Bloomberg that weakening encryption is a “red line” for Meta, warning the legislation risks turning private companies into “an arm of the government’s surveillance apparatus.“
Why technology companies are upset with Bill C-22
The standoff centers on Part 2 of Bill C-22, which grants ministers the authority to issue confidential orders compelling tech companies to build law enforcement access capabilities into their platforms. The provision also allows the government to require companies to retain customer metadata—including IP addresses and connection logs—for up to six months.While Ottawa introduced amendments barring orders that create a “systemic vulnerability,” tech leaders and cybersecurity experts contend the language is overly vague. Cryptographers and privacy advocates have long maintained that it is impossible to build a “backdoor” exclusively for police without leaving that same entry point exposed to cybercriminals and foreign intelligence agencies.The primary flashpoint is Part 2 of the bill, which grants ministers in the country the authority to issue confidential orders forcing service providers to build interception capabilities for police. The legislation also empowers the government to require companies to retain sensitive customer metadata—including IP addresses and connection logs—for up to six months.While Ottawa introduced amendments prohibiting orders that create a “systemic vulnerability,” tech leaders and cryptographers argue the language is dangerously vague. Security experts maintain that creating a “backdoor” for law enforcement inevitably creates a weak point that malicious hackers and foreign spies will eventually exploit.Meta is far from alone in its opposition, joining a broad coalition of tech giants, privacy-focused apps, and digital rights advocates pushing back against the draft law. Both Google and Apple have issued warnings that Bill C-22 threatens customer security and could break end-to-end encryption.Encrypted messaging platform Signal too has stated that it would leave Canada rather than compromise its security protocols, while Toronto-based VPN provider Windscribe pledged to maintain its strict no-logs policy regardless of the bill’s outcome.