NEW DELHI: A district consumer commission in Kerala has directed Etihad Airways to pay Rs 25,000 compensation and Rs 5,000 litigation costs to a passenger whose checked-in luggage went missing during an eight-day international pilgrimage tour. It held that the airline was deficient in service for failing to ensure timely delivery of his baggage, though the passenger had also contributed to his predicament by packing cash and essential medicines in it.
Case background
As per the commission order, Alfred Varghese was part of an eight-day group pilgrimage tour booked with Etihad Airways. The journey began from Thiruvananthapuram on December 20, 2015, and was scheduled to end on December 28. The tour covered Abu Dhabi, Jordan, Israel, Palestine and Egypt, for which he paid Rs 85,000.When Varghese arrived at Queen Alia Airport in Amman, Jordan, he found that his checked-in luggage had not arrived. The bag contained his clothes, cash, toiletries and essential medicines. He immediately reported the missing baggage to the airline’s airport office.Varghese alleged that he suffered mental agony and hardship as he had no clothes to change, money to make purchases or medicines for his heart-related disorder. He said he had been taking regular medicines since 2007 and travelling without them posed a risk to his health.He further alleged that he requested the airline to arrange his return to India if the baggage could not be traced before his next flight, but the request was refused.The airline later traced the baggage, but it was sent to Thiruvananthapuram after Varghese had left Jordan. He alleged that despite repeated communications, the airline did not arrange to deliver it at any of the destinations during the remaining tour. The airline apologised and offered $40 through an email dated March 31, 2016. Varghese approached the commission alleging deficiency in service and unfair trade practice and sought Rs 2 lakh compensation.In its written statement, the airline admitted that his checked-in baggage was short-landed at Amman airport but denied that it contained essential medicines. It argued that its conditions of carriage prohibited passengers from keeping cash and essential medicines in checked-in baggage.The airline also said Varghese should have approached the tour operator for arrangements to return to India. It claimed the baggage was made available at Amman the next day, but he had already left for another destination. It further said he had not submitted bills for emergency purchases of clothes and toiletries despite being asked to do so for reimbursement.
Commission’s findings
The bench of president P V Jayarajan and members Preetha G Nair and Viju V R held that the airline was deficient in service for failing to ensure timely delivery of the baggage. However, it also found that Varghese had contributed to his predicament by packing cash and essential medicines in checked-in luggage.The commission said an airline accepting checked-in baggage is duty-bound to ensure its safe and timely delivery.“Once an airline accepts checked-in baggage from a passenger, it is duty-bound to ensure the safe and timely delivery of the same at the destination. The short-landing of baggage, resulting in a passenger being deprived of his personal belongings and clothing throughout an eight-day international pilgrimage tour, undoubtedly constitutes deficiency in service on the part of the carrier,” the bench said.However, relying on Article 8.3.4 of the airline’s General Conditions of Carriage and the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission’s ruling in Shiv Garg v. Lufthansa German Airlines & Ors, it said passengers are advised against packing cash, valuables and essential medicines in checked-in baggage.The commission also noted that Varghese had not produced bills for emergency purchases. It found no evidence to establish his allegation of unfair trade practice.The bench said being without luggage, fresh clothes and basic necessities during an eight-day international journey would naturally cause stress and discomfort. It rejected the airline’s USD 40 offer as inadequate.“The Opposite Party’s unilateral offer of $40 is wholly disproportionate to the inconvenience suffered by the complainant, a senior citizen passenger over an eight-day international journey,” the bench added.It held that the Rs 2 lakh compensation claim was on the higher side, considering the passenger’s contributory lapse and the absence of bills proving additional expenses.
Final order
Announced on November 12, 2026, the order partly allowed the complaint. The commission directed Etihad Airways to pay:
- Rs 25,000 as compensation for mental agony, physical discomfort and inconvenience.
- Rs 5,000 towards litigation expenses.
The airline must make the payment within 30 days of receiving the order, failing which the compensation amount, excluding litigation costs, will carry 9% annual interest from the date of the order until realisation.