Headlines

A shop owner insured her clothes, Jaipuri Thewa jewellery and other stock, but after heavy rain damaged the goods, the insurer rejected her claim over missing documents; consumer commission orders it to pay Rs 4.9 lakh with 9% interest


A shop owner insured her clothes, Jaipuri Thewa jewellery and other stock, but after heavy rain damaged the goods, the insurer rejected her claim over missing documents; consumer commission orders it to pay Rs 4.9 lakh with 9% interest
AI generated image used for representative purpose

NEW DELHI: A consumer commission in Haryana has held National Insurance Company guilty of deficiency in service for closing a shop owner’s insurance claim as ‘No Claim’ after heavy rain damaged her stock, despite her submitting documents detailing the loss. It directed the insurer to pay Rs 4.8 lakh with 9 percent annual interest, along with Rs 10,000 towards compensation and litigation costs.

Insurance company closes shop owner’s rain damage claim

According to the commission order, Kanika, a 39-year-old shop owner from Rohtak, had insured the stock in her shop with National Insurance Company under a policy valid from October 21, 2021, to October 20, 2022. The policy covered clothes, Jaipuri Thewa jewellery, Jaipuri suits and other stock worth up to Rs 20 lakh.On June 30, 2022, heavy rain damaged the entire stock lying in her shop. The complainant said she immediately informed the insurance company’s agent and shared photographs and videos of the damaged goods.The insurer registered her claim and appointed a surveyor, Sunil Vashishth, to inspect the premises and assess the loss. The surveyor asked her to submit documents, including stock records, income tax returns, balance sheets and details of the damaged goods.Kanika maintained that she had submitted the required documents. However, the insurance company sent letters dated November 2 and December 8, 2022, claiming that certain documents were still missing.On December 26, 2022, the insurer informed her that the claim had been closed as ‘No Claim’.After repeated requests failed to yield any result, she sent a legal notice on February 3, 2023. She then approached the consumer commission seeking Rs 4,80,242 towards the loss, along with compensation and litigation expenses.The insurance company argued that the address of the insured premises did not match the location of the shop where the damage occurred. It also claimed that the complainant had failed to immediately inform it about the incident and submit the required documents despite repeated reminders.

Why commission held insurance company liable

The bench comprising president Nagender Singh Kadian and members Dr Tripti Pannu and Dr Vijender Singh rejected the insurance company’s objections.On the address issue, the commission noted that the insurer had failed to produce evidence showing that the damaged stock was kept at premises other than the insured location.It also accepted the complainant’s explanation for the delay in submitting written intimation. She had shared photographs and videos with the insurer’s agent on June 30, 2022, while written intimation was submitted on July 4 after the weekend.The bench further noted that the insurer had not produced copies of the emails it claimed to have sent seeking additional documents. On the other hand, the complainant had submitted an email dated November 5, 2022, along with 31 documents and photographs.The commission observed that the insurer had neither properly examined these records nor produced an assessment report showing that the claimed loss was incorrect.“The surveyor was appointed by the insurance company for inspecting the premises and assessing the loss. Once the complainant had furnished the relevant documents, it was the responsibility of the surveyor to examine the same and prepare an assessment report. If any further document or clarification was required, the same should have been specifically communicated to the complainant,” the commission said.It further observed that the insurer could not reject the claim by blaming the complainant for missing documents when it had failed to establish what was actually required.“The insurance company cannot take advantage of its own failure to assess the loss and then reject the claim on the ground of non-submission of documents,” it added.The bench accepted the claimed loss of Rs 4,80,242 and held that closing the insurance claim without a specific and justified reason amounted to deficiency in service.

Final order

The commission directed National Insurance Company to:

  • Pay Rs 4,80,242 towards the loss, with 9 percent annual interest from March 21, 2023, until realisation.
  • Pay Rs 5,000 as compensation for mental agony and harassment.
  • Pay Rs 5,000 towards litigation expenses.
  • The insurer has been directed to comply with the order within 30 days of receiving a copy of it.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *