Headlines

Arizona parents wanted to replace a backyard gate so their disabled son could park his golf cart at home, but their HOA refused; an appeals court has rejected the association’s attempt to force private arbitration


Arizona parents wanted to replace a backyard gate so their disabled son could park his golf cart at home, but their HOA refused; an appeals court has rejected the association's attempt to force private arbitration

An Arizona couple who wanted to replace a backyard gate so their disabled son could park his golf cart at home have won a legal fight against their homeowners’ association (HOA). An appeals court turned down the association’s effort to force the family into private arbitration, allowing their lawsuit to move forward in court. Kevin and Jennifer LoPresto had asked the Wigwam Creek South Community Association to let them swap their single gate for a wider double gate. They explained that the wider opening was needed so their disabled son could park his golf cart in the backyard. The association denied their request and later argued that the dispute had to be settled through private arbitration instead of a public court.However, the Arizona Court of Appeals backed the lower court’s refusal to order arbitration. In its September 25, 2026, memorandum decision, the court ruled that the arbitration rules used by the association were one-sided and could not be enforced against the couple. This ruling means the LoPrestos can keep fighting their case against the HOA in court. The appeals judges also granted the couple reasonable legal fees and court costs tied to the appeal. According to the decision posted by Justia, the case focuses on the association’s rules, the couple’s request to change their gate, and whether the HOA could force residents to settle disagreements through a private arbitration process.

Request to replace backyard gate rejected

Kevin and Jennifer LoPresto live in the planned neighborhood of Wigwam Creek South in Arizona. The community is run by the Wigwam Creek South Community Association and follows a set of rules called the Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions. These rules control how properties in the neighborhood can be used and what changes homeowners can make to their houses and yards.In November 2024, the couple sent in a formal request to replace their single gate with a double gate. According to the court’s decision, the goal was to allow “their disabled son [could] park his golf cart in the backyard.” The association turned down the application. The LoPrestos challenged that choice, but the HOA stood by its refusal after reviewing their complaint.That disagreement eventually pushed the couple to go to court. In April 2025, Kevin and Jennifer filed a lawsuit against the association. They accused the HOA of breaking its contract duties and failing to act fairly when handling requests from homeowners. Their lawsuit argued that the HOA failed to follow the community’s main rules, especially the duty to “enforce the rules and regulations . . . fairly, impartially, and without selective enforcement.” The couple’s court case centered on how the association handled their request and its duties under the neighborhood’s governing rules.

HOA wanted dispute settled through arbitration

Instead of letting the lawsuit move forward in court, the Wigwam Creek South Community Association asked the trial judge to send the fight to private arbitration. The association pointed to arbitration rules written in two documents. These were the community’s Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions and a second rulebook called the Wigwam Creek South Community Association Guidelines for Community Living. The HOA claimed these rules forced the LoPrestos to settle their complaints through arbitration. It argued that the rules applied to the couple’s claims and had to be followed.Arbitration is a process where a disagreement is settled outside the regular court system by an independent person or panel. People often use it to resolve contract fights without holding a full court trial. The association asked the Superior Court to force the couple to go through this process. The trial judge said no. The HOA then asked the court to clarify and rethink that choice, but the judge did not change the refusal to order arbitration. The association then appealed to the Arizona Court of Appeals, claiming the lower court had made an error.

Appeals court finds arbitration rules one-sided

The appeals court looked closely at both arbitration rules and decided that neither one could be enforced against the LoPrestos. In its ruling, the court noted that Arizona law generally supports written arbitration agreements as a way to settle fights quickly and for less money. Still, an agreement must meet basic fairness standards to hold up in court. The judges pointed to an earlier Arizona case, Stevens/Leinweber/Sullens, Inc. v. Holm Development and Management, Inc., which established that a one-sided arbitration rule can be considered substantively unconscionable. In plain terms, this means an agreement can be legally unfair because it puts strict rules on one side without placing similar duties on the other side.The court decided that the arbitration rule in the community’s main declaration was one-sided. Under subsection 12.8.2, homeowners and other people covered by the declaration had to take their claims to arbitration. Yet subsection 12.8.1(a) excused the homeowners’ association from that exact same requirement. The judges also pointed out that subsection 4.2 allowed the HOA to go to court to force residents to follow the declaration. This setup meant homeowners could be forced into private arbitration when suing the association, while the association kept the freedom to take disputes to court. The appeals court agreed that the lower court was right to call the rule unfair and unenforceable.

Separate community guidelines also rejected

The HOA also tried to use a second arbitration rule written in its Guidelines for Community Living. It argued that Section V of the guidelines was a separate, more specific rule that covered the LoPrestos’ complaint. According to the association, this rule stayed valid even if the arbitration clause in the main declaration could not be used. The lower court had earlier questioned whether Section V had been properly approved as part of the original rules voted on by homeowners. It also questioned whether that rule matched the arbitration terms in the main declaration.The appeals court said it did not even need to answer those questions. Instead, the judges read the exact words of Section V and spotted another flaw. That rule applied when “any Owner has a dispute” with the HOA. The court noted that this wording only forced homeowners to take their fights to binding arbitration. It did not place that same duty on the association when the HOA took legal action against a homeowner. Because of this, the judges ruled that Section V was also one-sided. For the exact same reason as the arbitration rule in the main declaration, it was found to be unfair and unenforceable. The court turned down the association’s appeal and backed the lower court’s refusal to send the fight to arbitration.

Couple awarded legal costs

The appeals court also reviewed the LoPrestos’ request to get back the legal money they spent defending the lower court’s ruling. The couple asked for attorneys’ fees and court costs under sections 12-341.01 and 12-342 of Arizona law. The judges agreed to grant them reasonable legal fees and taxable costs for the appeal. They explained that the fight grew out of a contract dispute and the LoPrestos had successfully defended the lower court’s ruling. This money award depends on the couple following the proper filing steps under Arizona Rule of Civil Appellate Procedure 21.The September 25, 2026, ruling came from the Arizona Court of Appeals, Division One. Presiding Judge Jennifer M. Perkins wrote the decision, and Judges Brian Y. Furuya and D. Andrew Gaona agreed with her. The ruling is an unpublished memorandum decision and is not precedential under Arizona Supreme Court Rule 111(c), which means it generally cannot be cited as binding law in future cases. The appeals court upheld the lower court’s decision, leaving the LoPrestos free to pursue their original lawsuit against the Wigwam Creek South Community Association without being forced into private arbitration. This ruling does not decide whether the HOA must allow the double gate or settle the couple’s main complaints. Those questions remain separate from the arbitration fight.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *