Headlines

A Wisconsin couple wanted to build a backyard fence for their children with special needs, but the HOA refused; years after the $200,000 settlement, they have filed a new lawsuit against 55 neighbours who are yet to pay


A Wisconsin couple wanted to build a backyard fence for their children with special needs, but the HOA refused; years after the $200,000 settlement, they have filed a new lawsuit against 55 neighbours who are yet to pay

Homeowners Lisa and Michael Newman are back in court, this time against the homeowners association in their De Pere subdivision and dozens of neighbours who never paid their share of an earlier settlement. The couple filed the new suit this autumn, according to NBC 26, nearly two years after their original legal battle over the HOA’s refusal to let them build a backyard fence for their five children with special needs. The case now asks whether the association can be held liable for money its members still owe.

A dispute over the fence

The Newmans bought their home in the Nazcr Trac subdivision in 2017, before any of their children had been diagnosed with autism. Their first child received a diagnosis shortly after the move, a second followed in 2018, and a third in 2020. Because of their conditions, all three children were “unable to understand dangerous situations or monitor their own safety” and “require extra supervision to prevent them from running away”. All three have wandered away from their parents or caregivers on several occasions. The family’s request for a backyard fence grew directly out of those safety concerns, according to the court ruling. A fence would let the children play outside without the constant risk of slipping away.The Newmans sued the Nazcr Trac Homeowners Association after it denied permission to build a fence. The couple wanted a backyard fence for their home in De Pere, Wisconsin, because their children have special needs. Following the HOA’s refusal, they took the matter to court. That lawsuit ended with the association agreeing to pay the Newmans $200,000. Under the deal, each homeowner in the subdivision was expected to chip in $1,350.

Not every neighbour was ready to pay

The settlement was supposed to end the dispute. However, not every neighbour was enthusiastic about paying their share. Sixty-nine homeowners paid their part after the original lawsuit, but many others did not. Some residents said they had never heard of the fence dispute until the settlement was announced, and they felt the decision had been made without them.One homeowner who received a judgment initially refused to pay. He changed his mind only after getting legal advice. Others stayed quiet, and some are now facing the consequences.Some neighbours described the latest development as a sense of déjà vu. “Why is this coming back to us? It’s so unfair,” one homeowner, who chose to remain anonymous, told the network.A few others wondered why they had to chip in when they had nothing to do with the dispute. “I did nothing wrong. Why should I pay?” another anonymous homeowner asked.

The rest still owe the money

Whether the remaining 55 homeowners have to pay is still a matter of debate, but attorney Victoria Davis Dávila, who represents the Newmans, says they still owe the money. “There’s an outstanding judgment. You had the opportunity to pay. You chose not to pay it,” attorney Victoria Davis Dávila said.The new lawsuit names the homeowners association along with the homeowners who have not paid. The attorney also warned that if the balance remains unpaid, the association as a whole could be held responsible. That prospect has left people who have already paid feeling stuck in a problem they did not create.One resident who settled his share said the uncertainty had led him to consider moving away from the neighbourhood. He described the situation in a way that many neighbours seemed to share: nobody knows what happens next.Meanwhile, according to the neighbours, the association is looking for legal representation to respond to the new complaint, and its response is due this week. The Newmans want the matter over as much as anyone, their attorney said.For now, though, a fence that was never built still sits at the centre of a neighbourhood that cannot agree on who should pay for it.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *