A Rs 29.87 crore addition to the income of a US citizen working in India was deleted after ITAT found the tax officer had compared foreign bank peak balances without properly examining deposits, withdrawals and transfers


A Rs 29.87 crore addition to the income of a US citizen working in India was deleted after ITAT found the tax officer had compared foreign bank peak balances without properly examining deposits, withdrawals and transfers
AI generated image used for representative purpose

NEW DELHI: The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi, has dismissed the tax department’s appeal against the deletion of a Rs 29.87 crore addition made to the income of a US citizen over an increase in the peak balances of his foreign bank accounts.In an order dated November 18, 2026, the tribunal held that the increase in account balances alone could not be treated as unexplained income. It also upheld the deletion of a separate Rs 5.36 lakh addition on interest earned from these accounts.

Case background

The case concerns Deepak Lal Agarwal, a US citizen working in India with Cairn India Limited. He filed his income tax return for the assessment year 2017-18, declaring an income of Rs 8.67 crore.During scrutiny, the assessing officer noticed that the combined highest balances in his foreign bank accounts had increased from Rs 10.82 crore in 2015-16 to Rs 40.70 crore in 2016-17. The officer treated the difference of Rs 29.87 crore as unexplained money. He also found that Agarwal had earned Rs 5.36 lakh as interest from these accounts.The officer added both amounts to his taxable income under Section 69A of the Income Tax Act and as interest income, taking his total assessed income to Rs 38.59 crore.Agarwal challenged the assessment before the National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi. He submitted foreign bank statements and explained that the increase in balances included salary already declared in India and transfers between his own bank accounts. He argued that the same money had been counted more than once while calculating the increase.On the interest income, he argued that he was entitled to be treated as a US tax resident under the India-US tax treaty and that the interest was taxable in the US.The NFAC accepted his explanations and deleted both additions.The income tax department challenged this decision before the ITAT. It argued that Agarwal had failed to explain the foreign bank deposits during the assessment and that the NFAC had wrongly accepted additional documents without following the prescribed procedure.Agarwal opposed the appeal, saying the bank statements and other documents had been examined by the assessing officer during the appeal proceedings and no discrepancies were found.

What did the tribunal say?

The bench comprising Mahavir Singh (vice president) and S Rifaur Rahman (accountant member) noted that the assessing officer had compared the highest bank balances of two financial years without properly examining the deposits, withdrawals and transfers between accounts.It said the difference between the highest balances in two years could not automatically be treated as unexplained income.“We noticed that the AO had compared the peak balance of two years, this itself cannot be treated as income of the assessee,” the tribunal observed.It also noted that Agarwal had submitted bank statements and other documents explaining the transactions. The assessing officer had examined these documents during the remand proceedings but had not pointed out any discrepancies.“We do not see any reason to disturb the detailed findings of ld. CIT(A),” it added.On the Rs 5.36 lakh interest income, the tribunal upheld the NFAC’s decision to apply the India-US tax treaty’s rules for determining a person’s tax residency when both countries consider them their resident. It found no reason to interfere with the relief granted to Agarwal.The tribunal also rejected the department’s objection that the NFAC had violated Rule 46A by accepting additional documents. It noted that the documents had been sent to the assessing officer for examination and a remand report had been obtained before the NFAC decided the appeal.

Final order

Pronounced on November 18, 2026, the ITAT dismissed the income tax department’s appeal and upheld the deletion of both additions:

  • Rs 29,87,11,506 added as unexplained money under Section 69A of the Income Tax Act.
  • Rs 5,36,709 added as interest income from foreign bank accounts.

The tribunal also rejected the department’s challenge to the admission of additional evidence, leaving the relief granted to Agarwal unchanged.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *