A Louisiana farmer returned from offshore work in March 2013 to find neighbours clearing trees and brush from a strip of land he believed belonged to him. The neighbours thought the land was part of their property because an old fence marked what they considered their boundary.The disagreement eventually turned into a 13-year legal battle. Now, the Louisiana Court of Appeal has upheld the farmer’s ownership of the disputed land and ordered his neighbours to pay $59,966.99 for the damage caused by the clearing and changes to the property’s drainage, according to Law Justia.The ruling was delivered on November 18, 2026, in the case of Benjamin Lee Bird v. William Eric Gill and Rhonda Marie Olivo Gill. According to the court’s judgment, the dispute involved an 18-foot-wide strip measuring about 0.879 acres in Franklin Parish, Louisiana.
An old fence led to a boundary dispute
According to Law Justia, Benjamin Lee Bird bought his 114-acre property in 2004. His neighbours, William Eric Gill and Rhonda Marie Olivo Gill, bought an adjoining 100-acre property in March 2013.An old fence had been installed along the southern part of Bird’s land sometime between 1988 and 1990. However, it did not follow the actual surveyed property boundary. An 18-foot strip between the fence and the Gills’ legally established northern boundary therefore became the centre of the dispute.Before buying their property, William Gill inspected it with a farmer, David Fortenberry, to see whether it could be used for growing row crops. The previous owner told him that everything inside the fence belonged to the property.The Gills did not get a survey when they purchased the land. After the sale, William hired Fortenberry to prepare the property for farming and instructed him to work inside the fence. Fortenberry and another worker, Carey Williamson, began clearing trees and carrying out drainage work. When Bird returned from offshore work, he found that they were also working on the disputed strip.Bird told Williamson that he claimed ownership of approximately 20 feet of land beyond the fence. William Gill arrived, and the two men argued about where the boundary lay. Bird claimed that Gill said, “Let him waste his money on an attorney. I own it.” The court noted that there were no witnesses to this conversation.
Clearing continued despite the disagreement
William Gill later spoke to his lawyer about the boundary. He said he understood from that conversation that the old fence might establish ownership. However, the lawyer testified that he did not remember the discussion and would not have advised anyone about ownership without qualifications. The court noted that neither side obtained a survey before the clearing work resumed.The workers removed and burned the trees and brush from the disputed strip. They also dug a new ditch across the land and used the removed soil to fill an existing ditch and other holes on the Gills’ property. The Gills then levelled their land and created a slope that directed water north towards Bird’s property. Bird said the changes increased flooding on his land.He filed a lawsuit on August 27, 2013, claiming ownership of the strip and accusing the neighbours of trespassing, removing trees and damaging the land. The Gills disputed his claim and argued that they had acquired ownership through long-term possession.
A long court battle
Photo: Canva
The case went through several stages. An initial judgment in 2018 recognised Bird’s ownership and awarded him damages. However, the Gills obtained a new trial after the court accepted that their lawyers’ staff had made an honest scheduling mistake.The second trial took place over four days between December 2020 and October 2021. The trial court issued its final judgment in January 2026, again recognising Bird’s ownership and awarding him $81,746.99. The Gills appealed both the ownership decision and the amount of damages.In its November 18 ruling, the Louisiana Second Circuit Court of Appeal upheld the decision recognising Bird’s ownership. It also agreed that the neighbours were responsible for the damage caused by the clearing and changes to the land.
Why the compensation was reduced
The appeals court reviewed each part of the damages awarded by the lower court. It upheld $45,000 for dirt work and drainage repairs, finding that the evidence supported the cost of restoring the land. An expert had estimated that the work would require more than 5,000 cubic yards of soil, along with heavy machinery and labour.The court also upheld $10,000 for replacing the removed trees. It noted that the trees had been burned, making it difficult to establish their exact number and type. Bird had estimated that around 130 trees were removed, while the neighbours’ witnesses suggested that the number was much lower.However, the judges reduced the compensation for lost shade. The lower court had awarded $13,920 for three sheds, but the appeals court said the value of the replacement trees already included the shade they would provide. It allowed Bird $4,640 to reimburse him for one shed he had actually built to provide shade for his cattle while the case was pending.The court also removed the $2,500 award for fence repairs because there was not enough evidence showing the fence’s condition before and after the clearing work. It cancelled the $10,000 awarded for mental anguish as well.The judges said Bird had not provided sufficient evidence of actual psychological injury caused by the property damage. The final compensation was therefore reduced from $81,746.99 to $59,966.99. The amount includes $45,000 for drainage and dirt work, $10,000 for tree replacement, $4,640 for shade replacement and $326.99 for a water trough.