A London professor and his wife ended up facing a legal bill of around £180,000 after a dispute with their neighbour over the sale of their flat. Professor Daslav Brkic had sought £80,000 in damages from Douglas Palin, claiming that his disclosures about their past property disagreements had put off prospective buyers and made their £680,000 home difficult to sell.According to The Independent, the case went to trial for a week before Judge Nigel Gerald dismissed the claim. The judge found that Palin was entitled to share factual information with a prospective buyer and that there was insufficient evidence that his disclosures had caused the buyer to withdraw. Brkic and his wife were ordered to pay Palin’s estimated £45,000 legal costs, in addition to their own expenses of about £135,000.
What led to the neighbours’ long-running property dispute
Brkic and his wife bought the ground-floor and garden apartment in a Victorian building in Alexandra Grove, Finsbury Park, in 2013. Palin, a wine retailer, owned the freehold and lived in an upper-floor flat. The couple undertook extensive refurbishment, which led to disagreements with Palin. These included disputes over flooring, windows, burglar bars and electrical cabling.In 2021, Palin took the couple to a tribunal over their removal of carpets, which breached the lease. The tribunal ruled in Palin’s favour, and the couple later had the flat re-carpeted to address noise nuisance. The ruling went against Palin in a separate tribunal hearing over repeated inspections. The disagreements continued as the couple prepared to sell.
Why did Brkic blame Palin after a second buyer withdrew the offer
The couple decided to sell the flat in 2023. A £680,000 offer fell through early that year, while another buyer withdrew in August after offering about £640,000. Brkic blamed Palin for the second failed sale. He argued that Palin had included a list of complaints in a Leasehold Property Enquiries form supplied during the sale process. The disclosures referred to the resolved carpet dispute, earlier disagreements over windows and burglar bars, and a bathroom issue. The leasehold plan appeared to place part of the bathroom on Palin’s property, although this was later described as a mistake. Brkic’s barrister argued that most matters had already been resolved and should not have been raised.
The judge found no evidence that the disclosures caused the sale to fail
Palin told the court that the matters he disclosed were genuine concerns. Replacing sash windows in a Victorian property with UPVC could affect the value of the building as a whole. His barrister argued that he was entitled to make the disclosures and had acted prudently. Judge Gerald agreed that Palin had acted within his rights when completing the questionnaire. He said the form set out matters of historical fact and found no suggestion that Palin had acted dishonestly or in bad faith. The judge found no sufficient evidence that the information was the material or sole cause of the buyer’s withdrawal. The purchasers appeared to have withdrawn before receiving Palin’s comments.
Couple ordered to pay neighbour’s legal costs after claim was dismissed
The judge also rejected the argument that Palin’s disclosures had made the flat unsellable on the open market. By August 2024, all issues apart from cooking odours and electrical cabling had been formally resolved. He said he struggled to understand why the property could not be sold in those circumstances.The court also heard that Brkic and his wife had not disclosed some issues in their own property and leasehold information forms. Judge Gerald dismissed their claim and ordered them to pay Palin’s legal costs, estimated at £45,000. They were told to pay £30,000 within 28 days. The couple’s own legal costs were about £135,000, taking their total bill to approximately £180,000.Disclaimer: This article is based on publicly available reports. The Times of India has not independently verified the details of the property dispute, the claims made by either party, or the court proceedings.