A customer ordering an expensive phone from a major electronics retailer would reasonably expect the package to contain the device she had paid for. As reported by the BBC, when a woman bought an iPhone for £750 from Currys in Carlisle, she found a dummy handset inside instead of an actual Apple phone. She contacted the retailer to arrange a return, hoping the issue would be resolved.After sending the package back, she received what appeared to be the same fake phone. When she tried the process again, the replacement was identical. She eventually recovered her money through her bank, while a BBC Watchdog investigation uncovered similar complaints involving other high-value electronics sold by the retailer.
Woman’s £750 iPhone purchase turns into a repeated fake handset dispute
The customer, identified as Lucy in the BBC Watchdog investigation, had purchased an iPhone for £750 from Currys’ Carlisle store. The package she received, however, did not contain the Apple smartphone she had ordered. Instead, there was a dummy handset inside.Lucy contacted Currys and attempted to return the item. The first return did not resolve the problem. When another handset was sent to her, she discovered that it was the same fake device she had already received. She tried returning it once more, only to find herself in the same position.Despite the repeated attempts to get the matter sorted, Currys declined to issue a refund. Lucy eventually turned to her bank and managed to recover the £750 payment. Her experience formed part of a wider investigation into customers who said the products delivered to them did not match what they had purchased.
Customer finds two bags of rice instead of £3,300 MacBook
The investigation also heard from Andrew, who had spent £2,700 on an Apple MacBook. He had ordered a black model but received a silver laptop bearing marks left by old stickers. He suspected that the machine had previously been used and contacted Currys.The retailer asked him to return it. However, when a replacement arrived, Andrew took it to a Currys store and recorded the package being opened. The laptop inside was the very same machine he had sent back around three weeks earlier. His request for a refund was initially turned down.A subsequent check during the Watchdog investigation revealed that the laptop’s warranty had been activated 19 days before Andrew purchased it. He later received a full refund, along with compensation.Another customer, Lee, had paid £3,300 for an Apple MacBook from Currys in Aldershot. Instead of finding a computer when he opened the package, he discovered two bags of rice. As reported by the BBC, he contacted Apple and was told that the device’s 12-month warranty had already been activated 16 days before the purchase. Currys declined to reopen his complaint, but Lee eventually recovered the money through his bank. Currys is reimbursing the bank.
How criminals allegedly swapped expensive electronics before returning packages
The cases raised questions about how products could be returned to the retailer and subsequently reach other customers without the original contents being checked. The watchdog’s investigation uncovered similar incidents in different parts of the UK, suggesting that the complaints could not simply be attributed to an isolated incident involving one individual.The programme examined the possibility of a retail fraud operation in which criminals replace expensive electronic products with cheaper items before returning the packages. High-value devices, including smartphones and laptops, are particularly attractive targets because the difference between the genuine product and its substitute can be substantial.In such cases, the original device is removed and something of little value is placed inside its packaging. If the returned parcel is not properly inspected, it can potentially enter the retailer’s stock again and be sold to another customer. That creates a cycle in which an unsuspecting buyer pays the full price for a product that is no longer inside the box.
What Currys said after customers reported fake iPhones and MacBooks replaced with rice
When approached by Watchdog with the allegations, Currys said it served millions of customers through its stores and online business each year. The retailer described cases in which customers received an incorrect order as exceptionally rare and said it would investigate such incidents to make sure they were put right.The outcomes differed between the customers featured in the programme. Andrew received a full refund and compensation from Currys, while Lee obtained his money back through his bank, with the retailer agreeing to reimburse it. Lucy also recovered her £750 after approaching her bank, having been unable to secure a refund directly from Currys.