PUNE: The Pune District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has directed an interior designer to pay over Rs 6.14 lakh, along with interest, to a woman for allegedly providing substandard interior work and defective furniture at her Balewadi flat.The commission partially allowed a complaint filed by Lopamudra Chakraborty against Dwipesh Barua, founder and proprietor of creArt – House of Interiors. The final order was passed on September 10, 2026, after proceedings that lasted over three years.According to the complaint, Chakraborty approached Barua in 2019 for interior work at her D-701 flat in 7 Avenue, Balewadi. The two entered into a residential interior design services agreement on April 28, 2019, with the work scheduled to be completed within 75 days, by July 10, 2019.The original estimated cost was Rs 9.83 lakh, but the designer collected Rs 11.21 lakh, citing an increase in raw material prices, the complaint stated.Chakraborty alleged that the designer used inferior-quality materials, delayed the work beyond the agreed deadline and left several defects unaddressed. She also claimed that the family faced inconvenience and health-related problems because of the condition of the unfinished interior work.Among the defects cited were cracks in the dining table, faulty measurements of the master bedroom furniture, peeling paint, cracks in the walls, rusting iron window grills, defective dressing table drawers and poorly fitted kitchen cabinets.The complainant also alleged that the dining table developed large cracks soon after delivery. Despite promising to replace it, the designer failed to do so. She eventually sought a refund of Rs 44,640 for the defective table. She also spent Rs 15,000 on a replacement bed-back cushion and Rs 7,500 on repairs to the master bedroom bed.The designer was proceeded against ex parte on July 22, 2024, after failing to appear before the commission despite publication of a public notice.Commission relies on expert reportThe commission examined the agreement, emails exchanged between the parties, photographs and an expert report dated February 17, 2023.The expert observed that the interior work was of extremely poor quality and lacked an attractive design. The report also pointed out that the designer had not taken the complainant’s prior approval for certain work and had failed to provide documents such as bills to establish that branded materials had been used.It further noted that the sofa had deteriorated soon after installation and required refurbishment, the plaster-of-Paris work had developed visible cracks, the window grills had rusted and the wooden work was of inferior quality.The expert estimated that replacing the defective interior work would cost around Rs 5 lakh.The commission observed that the designer had not appeared before it to contest the allegations or dispute the expert’s findings. It concluded that the complainant had established deficiencies in the services provided.What the commission orderedThe commission directed Barua to:
- Pay Rs 5 lakh towards the cost of rectifying the defective interior work, with 6% annual interest from September 2019.
- Refund Rs 9,974 collected for the bed-back cushion, with 6% annual interest from September 2019.
- Refund Rs 44,640 for the defective dining table, with 6% annual interest from September 2019. The complainant must return the table while receiving the refund.
- Pay Rs 50,000 as compensation for mental agony and Rs 10,000 towards litigation costs.
The amounts under the first three directions must be paid within 45 days of receiving the order. If the designer fails to comply within the stipulated period, the interest rate on those amounts will increase from 6% to 8% annually.The order was passed by commission president Anil B Jawalekar and member Shubhangi J Durnakhe.