Headlines

A Melbourne woman spent A$2,000 on four Apple gift cards at Coles, but discovered their redemption codes were scratched out; the supermarket initially refused a refund before agreeing to return her money |


A Melbourne woman spent A$2,000 on four Apple gift cards at Coles, but discovered their redemption codes were scratched out; the supermarket initially refused a refund before agreeing to return her money
Image Credit: AI Generated

A Melbourne woman who spent A$2,000 on four Apple gift cards at Coles discovered that their redemption codes had been scratched out, leaving her unable to use the vouchers. The purchase, which initially appeared to be a way to earn extra Flybuys points, turned into a frustrating dispute after supermarket staff reportedly refused to refund the money. The retailer eventually reversed its decision and agreed to return the amount. The incident later became part of a wider ABC News investigation into tampered gift cards being sold across Australia.

Melbourne woman’s A$2,000 Apple gift cards found with scratched-out codes

According to an ABC News investigation report published on May 21, 2026, Melbourne-based illustrator Georgia Perry bought four Apple gift cards from a Coles supermarket in Yarraville, an inner-western suburb of Melbourne. Each card was worth A$500, bringing the total purchase to A$2,000.Perry had purchased the vouchers on a Tuesday evening because she wanted to buy a new iPhone. An in-store promotion offering 20 times the usual Flybuys points on Apple gift card purchases also made the deal appear attractive.However, the purchase took an unexpected turn when she returned home and began opening the cards. The first voucher appeared to have no usable redemption code, with the area where the code should have been showing signs of scratching or peeling. Initially, Perry thought she might have damaged it while removing the card from its packaging.The same problem appeared on the remaining three cards. All four vouchers had their redemption codes scratched out, making them unusable for the intended purchase.

Why did Coles initially refuse to refund the money

Perry took the four vouchers back to the supermarket after discovering the damage. However, she told ABC News that the store staff were unwilling to help and reportedly explained that they could not take responsibility because gift cards were third-party products.She also contacted Apple for assistance. During the process, the company’s helpline asked her to provide photographs of the cards, including their serial numbers. This revealed another problem, as the final digits on the cards had also been scratched out.Perry subsequently lodged a formal complaint with Coles. The supermarket confirmed receiving it and said its customer care team had responded within an hour and continued working towards a resolution.The initial response left Perry dissatisfied. She described the customer service experience as uninterested and lacking urgency. She also questioned how the cards could have reached the shop floor in that condition, particularly because the damage was not obvious while they remained attached to their cardboard packaging.

How did Coles eventually agree to return the A$2,000

The situation changed after Perry shared a video of her experience on Instagram. Her complaint attracted widespread attention, receiving more than 150,000 views by the morning after it was posted, alongside hundreds of comments from people discussing gift card fraud and consumer rights.According to ABC News, a Coles employee left Perry a voicemail confirming that a refund would be issued. Emails reviewed by the ABC team showed that the gift card supplier had deactivated the A$2,000 worth of vouchers and returned the money to Coles.The supermarket subsequently informed Perry that she was eligible for a refund and apologised for the poor experience.

What did the ABC investigation discover about gift card fraud

In an extensive investigation published on August 31, 2026, ABC News revealed that shoppers across Australia had reported buying gift cards with missing or damaged redemption codes from major supermarket chains.The investigation examined 19 reports of suspicious gift cards, many involving Apple vouchers. It reviewed customer receipts, photographs of damaged cards and correspondence with retailers, Apple and gift card distributors.The earliest reports identified by the ABC dated back to 2024. That year, a Coles customer in Perth and a Woolworths shopper in Sydney reported problems with their purchases.The ABC investigation identified another customer, Lavkesh Arora, who bought five Apple gift cards worth A$2,000 from a Coles store in the city’s eastern suburbs. Two of the cards worth A$700 combined, had missing redemption codes and digits. Another shopper, Damian Toohey, reported finding a scratched-off number on an Apple gift card purchased from Woolworths.

How does the gift card tampering scam operate

The ABC investigation also examined how criminals could tamper with physical gift cards before returning them to supermarket shelves.Adam Parks, a former Australian representative of the US Department of Homeland Security’s investigative unit, explained that the practice is commonly known in the industry as card draining.According to Parks, the process can involve people taking gift cards from shop shelves, carefully opening their packaging and recording the information needed to access the funds. They may use razor blades or hair dryers to remove the packaging without leaving obvious signs of damage.The cards are then returned to their packaging and placed back on supermarket shelves. When an unsuspecting customer purchases one, the retailer activates it at the checkout.The stolen information can then be used to monitor the card’s balance and activation status. Once a customer pays for the voucher, those involved in the scam may spend its value before the buyer gets an opportunity to redeem it.This can make the fraud difficult to identify immediately. Gift cards are frequently purchased as presents, meaning some customers might not open them for weeks or months after the original transaction.Parks told ABC News that the operation becomes profitable when carried out on a large scale, with different people potentially handling the collection, tampering and use of the stolen information.

Are Australian supermarkets taking steps to prevent the problem

The ABC investigation found that Coles had previously worked with police to address gift card tampering. Court documents revealed that a man was arrested after allegedly placing tampered Apple gift cards on shelves on at least 5 Coles stores in Sydney.Police alleged that the cards involved were worth at least A$10,200. The man was sentenced to a two-year community corrections order and a 15-month suspended sentence.Both Coles and Woolworths acknowledged the wider problem and defended their efforts to prevent it. Woolworths was trialling anti-tamper hangers and staffed stations near gift card displays in some stores.Apple had also changed its Australian gift card packaging in early 2025. The newer design included perforated edges intended to make signs of opening or interference easier to identify. Its packaging also carried a warning against buying or selling cards that appeared to have been tampered with.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *